ot takes but they get progressively hotter (maybe)
1. Null & Void was the best event post solar eclipse
2. TDS' artstyle was better pre 2024
3. Evolved Towers should of replaced Golden Towers
4. the minigunner and ranger reworks were the biggest domino effect in this game's balancing
5. Frost mode should've never released
6. Most of the evolved towers aren't overpriced, if anything, they're underpriced
7. the difficulty difference between hardcore and voidcore has to change, its unironically as bad as legacy molten and legacy fallen
8. the later half of the survival modes should be significantly buffed
9. devs should nerf loss grinding or buff tirumph rewards
10. tds devs should stop trying to recreate what made certain events (halloween 2020, solar eclipse, frost invasion) fan favorites, they were loved because the amount of time it took in between each one and they were the first of their league, heavy emphasis on the night system
11. Event towers are the worst idea ever brought into the roblox tower defense genre, they created this invisible standard that is impossible to balance without having them being obtainable f2p, if an event tower is too weak, it'll be a trophy tower and nothing else, if it's too good, newgen players will complain about not having it and will also divide the game's community heavily
h
- 1
went 10/11 but tbh idc about the gap between hardcore and voidcore because one is for progression and one is solely for prestige
- 0
fair point but the fact to unlock voidcore you just need to beat hc, people around the skill level required to beat it will just assume its a decent upgrade to hardcore and not literally the hardest mode since 2020 hardcore
voidcore is an amazing mode and challenge i just hate how easy it is to unlock and how it can trick noobs into thinking its "oh hardcore but harder i could beat this"- 1
i didnt even know that i just assuemd it was a really high barrier
- 0
I do agree TDS artstyle is better, but some of the designs are not it, sometimes the old designs of some towers or hell even enemies were better, and shouldve only been adapted to a modern style
- 0Edited 1 hour ago
im not dissing the new models but the oversaturation(Especially in the lobby) and the lack of world building outside of events is kinda sad to me,
a paramilitary organisation would not have their headquarters have a commander falsity ball- 1Edited 1 hour ago
I mean... lobbies are not really canon, its shown that wherever the TDS headquarters is an entirely different place. TDS story has always been a mess, and just until now have they started to put duck tape all over it to try and make it comprehensible, which I dont think story mode really does well, and actually there isnt even much story from it so I understand the lack of world building complaint. (Also i need to start reading more properly, its the second time today I entirely misunderstand what someone is talking about)
- 1
True true
I still think the lobby should be somewhat représentative of what their base actually looks like, if they wanna start going deep into their story like Tdx (to be fair TDS only had a Decent story several years after its release, Tdx had one since release)
They should Atleast start with your first impression of the game
- 0
I honestly agree that frost mode shouldn’t have released
- 0
Without event towers there'd be no point for players to play events, without event towers there'd be no difference between old players and players who just have joined the game, event towers is some sort of a reward for playing the game, without event towers you'd was able to join the game at any moment without losing any opportunity, which would've was unefficient for the devs, the online of the game wouldn't change during events at all, and players would've just stop playing the game because they'd thought like "I can get it any moment later" and then just forget about the game, and the online of the game would've slowly decrease.
- 0
- 1Edited 1 hour ago
dude this entire reply isproving my point about events creating an unnecesarry standard
you don’t need event towers, its literally only done in the mainstream TD game genre because of TB and the earlier events of TDS
Also skins + achievements are a way to flex your Og status (if the devs didn’t keep readding them like the corporation they are)- 0
duck hunt proved u could have a succesful event that didnt have event towers. TDS said they'd stop doing event towers every event back during solar eclipse idk why they backtracked.
- 1Edited 1 hour ago
literally bro
and this isn't a "WAHH I DONT HAVE THESE EVENT TOWERS"
i have like every event tower in the game except for slasher, every one that was released after 2022 was thru their respective events
and they genuinely aren't healthy for the game
also if you look at another mainstream roblox td game, tdx, you can see how busted some of their towers are (as someone who has played the game since release), relic, cryo heli, cryo mortar and psycho slayer have created an insane division in between the community and that game's dev team have only started fixing it now- 0
i have every single event tower flat up and I still agree with you. I think event towers are fine but with how many tds has now (seriously 21 is insane) its just out of hand. The economy update plans to fix this so
- 0
Some of the old skins already has been returned, e.g. graveyard farm, crusader minigunner and all the Violent Night Battlepass Skins, it's no longer a reliable method to "flex". Without exclusive towers Events would've was nothing but a new limited gamemode.
- 1
"event would've been nothing but a new limited gamemode" ..
dude
that's what events fucking are
ALSO i did adress skins returning but this is still applicable to the fact that the only time this has happened were to the violent night skins (top 3 modern events btw) in 2023 and 2025, having these skins could still prove you're og (definitely not in 2025 but in 2023 i'd give you a pass) - 1
a seven year old game shouldnt be gatekeeping cosmetics that heavily unless they are intended to be extremely prestigious (ie champion accel or triumphant hacker). I dont see much reason to gatekeep much of the 2019-2020 skins anymore especially with the disproportionate gap between 2019-2020 skins and any skin after when it comes to tower reworks. For the commander rework they spent insane amounts of effort on gargoyle commander (halloween 2019), springtime commander (2020 easter code), bunny commander (easter 2020), and ghost commander (halloween 2020), and yet LITERALLY didnt do ANYTHING for eclipse commander and made minor changes to holiday commander, frost commander, etc. The same can be seen for medic have you SEEN witch, valentines, and bunny medic those are some of the rarest in the game yet they are INSANE. The ones that tds does decide to bring back are the lowest demand ones (the halloween 2023 crate was such a stinker the only high demand skins they brought back was graveyard farm and at the time pumpkin cowboy but thats been overshadowed nowadays)
To a new player if they didnt know towers like commander or medic didnt have their reworks during 2024-2025 it'd look like tds skins were better made during 2019-2020 then 2026 (atleast they get werewolf commander but still a lot of stinkers like teto commander). Even though when looking at commanders skin lineup during 2023 lets say before its rework most people would say all the skins post ghost commander were better (ghost skins were ass back then tho)- 0
i still kinda like the idea of making event stuff exclusive, but at most make it cosmetic
there is no reason for prime warlock, prime toxic gunner, current slasher and current star cannon to be locked behind a time limit and knowingly returning them for robux in the next few years- 0Edited 51 minutes ago
event towers during their respective events should be something like early access. Like with the economy update coming event towers should be kept behind its event during the event and like a month or two after the event they can be unlocked for chroma. Of course also reward the players who earned the event tower from the event with skins specially designed for that (they proposed this back in 2021, when tds was only through its 7th event out of the like 25 its been through now, and sledger was the 8th event tower out of 21).
Skins should get like 2-3 years to remain limited, then bring their respective series back (im sorry frost and eclipse skins back in 2023 I wanted to gatekeep you guys but I think its unreasonable now its been five years let the new players use eclipse commander and frost pyromancer)- 0
- 1
why dont they let me make the economy update for them bro i'd genuinely restore prime tds and finally make an event that surpasses solar eclipse
- 0
if only you didnt find jugg better than accel and engi below S tier
NOT JUGG SLANDER
NOT JUGG SLANDER BTW
JUGG IS INSANELY CLOSE TO ACCEL IN TERMS OF USABILITY- 0
im gonna take that as jugg slander you do not disrespect my semi goat
- 0
accel 💪
jugg 💪
those who compare
👀👀👀
- 0Edited 34 minutes ago
Oooh, crap, i haven't checked Trello in a long time... Well, if they will really release this update and it will work as i think it to, if the players will be able to craft old event skins and towers at any time, i will geniunely Unironically leave tds forever.
- 1
every skin in tds shouldnt be permanent but every limited skin should return at some point in the games life
- 0Edited 27 minutes ago
dude and the concept of "insanely rare skins" isn't out of the question, executioner's eclipse skin, harvester's toan skin (forgot the name), krampus cryomancer and gladiator's skin that was promised back in 2021-2022 are all examples of this working
why wouldnt it work in game?
even if triumphant hacker and champion accel are kinda controversial (triumphant hacker's controversy is fair because its mostly content creators who had hints and qa testers who beat hidden wave first) this can still work on proving OG status without being unfair for the noobs
oh shit i meant to reply to the other guy mb tehm- 0
There's no harvester toan skin, i'm pretty sure you're talking about Wastland harvester skin for which you was needed to do a quest
Also, the glue is not in proving that you're old player. The glue is that there'll be no difference between old players and new players. Both of them will have just as much as the other one. There will be no reward for you being old player, you will have just as much as the player who joined 4 months ago. Napoleon Bonaparte granted his first soldier the status of Soldats de ma Vieille Garde, as the reward for their loyalty, and if there will be no such thing in tds, there will be no more such disturbation as "old player", because both old and new players will have the same Privileges.
Imo ofc- 0
"wasteland harvester skin which you needed to do a quest" yeah.. thats the one im talking about.. i have it bro
"the glue is that there'll be no difference between old players and new players" you contradicted your own sentence by the usage of these adjectives bro
the difference between old players and new players is that old players have more experience, have alot more gamesense and usually are better players, im not against the idea of rewarding their long term commitment with cool cosmetics but with towers you're literally giving an advantage to a demographic that needs it the least
- 1
Objectively right on the last one
nothing besides cosmetics should be limited or locked behind a paywall
glad they are fixing it next year though
